Calvin Beisner
E. Calvin Beisner
Credentials
- Ph.D. Scottish History, University of St. Andrews (2003).[1](javascript:void(0))
- M.A. Society with a Specialization in Economic Ethics, International College (1983).[2](javascript:void(0))
- B.A. Interdisciplinary Studies in Religion and Philosophy, University of Southern California (1978).[3](javascript:void(0))
Background
E. Calvin Beisner is a former Professor of Social Ethics at Knox Theological Seminary. He was a member of the faculty as an associate professor of historical theology and social ethics from July 2000 through December 2007, but left Knox at the end of 2007.[4](javascript:void(0))
In May 2007 Beisner left the PCA to help plant a new Orthodox Presbyterian Church congregation. He has served on the pastoral staff of Holy Trinity Presbyterian Church (OPC).[5](javascript:void(0))
Beisner is known as a “leading evangelical climate-change skeptic,” and founder of the Cornwall Alliance for the Stewardship of Creation.[6](javascript:void(0)) He has been called “the most influential evangelical anti-environmentalist in the United States.”[7](javascript:void(0))
According to Beisner’s personal website, he was a ruling elder of the Presbyterian Church in America. His profile also adds that Beisner has testified before the U.S. Senate on climate change, spoken at the 2008, 2009, and 2010 International Conferences on Climate Change hosted by the Heartland Institute, and has given talks the Heritage Foundation and the Family Research Council, and was a guest on Fox News. Besiner designed the Cornwall Alliance’s DVD series “Resisting the Green Dragon.”[8](javascript:void(0))
Among his affiliations, Beisner is an adjunct fellow of the Acton Institute for the Study of Religion and Liberty, an adjunct scholar of the Committee for a Constructive Tomorrow, a fellow of the Institute on Religion and Democracy; and a member of the advisory board of the Templeton Freedom Awards program of the Atlas Economic Research Foundation (now the Atlas Network.)[9](javascript:void(0))
Stance on Climate Change
May 2017
Calvin Beisner was hosted on a speaking tour in Canada where he spoke in several provinces. He expressed the following at a talk in Alberta, asserting he was not a climate change “denier”:[10](javascript:void(0))
“Do I believe that global warming is real? Absolutely. Sure. And I also believe that global cooling is real. Warming and cooling have gone back and forth cyclically throughout Earth’s history. Whether you’re somebody who believes in an Earth that’s billions of years old, or somebody who believes in an Earth that is perhaps eight or ten thousand years old, either way, Earth’s history shows us that warming and cooling have gone back and forth cyclically all through Earth’s history.
[…] So, do I believe global warming is real? Yes. So, I’m not a climate change denier. I’m certainly not a climate denier.”
However, Beisner clarified that any warming that does occur would be “So little we cannot detect it. And if it’s that little, then it’s not going to have all kinds of disastrous effects.”[11](javascript:void(0))
October 1999
Beisner is a signatory[12](javascript:void(0)) to the The Cornwall Declaration on Environmental Stewardship, which states that there are “Some unfounded or undue concerns include fears of destructive manmade global warming, overpopulation, and rampant species loss.”[13](javascript:void(0))
Key Quotes
September 25, 2019
Speaking to legislators and energy industry representatives at the 59th Annual Meeting of the Southern States Energy Board (SSEB), Beisner declared that energy companies should embrace CO2 emissions:[14](javascript:void(0))
“CO2 is the elixir of life. The world needs more of it not less. And fossil fuel companies should stop apologizing for it and embracing trends of emissions reductions. It never ceases to amaze me that fossil fuel companies, and industries that use fossil fuels, boast of reducing CO2 emissions. That just means pleading guilty and then begging for delayed execution.”[15](javascript:void(0))
You should be boasting all the benefits […] that the world gets not just from all that energy that you produce but also from a mere byproduct your activities, a byproduct you give to all the world without charging them a penny.”[16](javascript:void(0))
January 31, 2018
Following President Donald Trump‘s State of the Union Address, Beisner said in a statement:[17](javascript:void(0))
“The utter absence of climate change from President Trump’s State of the Union Address stands in stark contrast to its prominence in all of former President Obama’s speeches. Whether climate alarmists here and abroad like it or not, their pet topic has fallen off the agenda for the highest official in the world’s most powerful nation and its biggest economy. Just as the Department of Defense no longer includes climate change as a national security risk, Trump no longer includes it as a risk to America or the world. His boosting coal is a clear sign that the federal government’s love affair with diffuse, expensive, unreliable renewable energy sources like wind and solar is over. That’s good news for Americans, yes. But it’s especially good news for the poor in developing countries. Western environmentalist elites, dominating the United Nation’s Environment Program and the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, have bullied them for years against using coal to lift their people out of poverty. Trump’s policies give them cover to buck that bullying and put their people’s needs first.”[18](javascript:void(0))
May 2017
Speaking at an event hosted by Reformed Perspective, as part of a Canadian speaking tour, Beisner said:
“If we reduce our use of CO2 we will not make any significant difference in global average surface temperature […] Poverty is a far greater risk than anything having to do with climate. […] Poverty kills. Wealth keeps alive.”[19](javascript:void(0)) [20](javascript:void(0))
December 2016
“One can’t help wondering if his [Pope Francis’s] embrace of climate alarmism rests on politics rather than science.
[…] “President-elect Trump, at whom the pontiff was preaching, should stick to his guns. He should announce that because President Obama never submitted the Paris treaty to the Senate for ratification, which the Constitution requires for the United States to be bound by any treaty, the U.S. is not a party to the treaty. Then, on the day he’s inaugurated, he should submit the treaty to the Senate, where it will die the ignominious death it deserves.”[21](javascript:void(0))
July 2016
“Even if global warming contributed to rising temperature and declining rainfall, human activity needn’t have driven it. The computer models on which the IPCC depends simulate warming from rising atmospheric CO2 at two to three times the observed rate, and none simulated the absence of observed warming from early 1997 to late 2015. So they are tenuous reasons to believe human activity was the main driver.
“At most, human activity contributed a fraction of observed warming, so only a fraction of the rise in temperature and decline in rainfall, and only a fraction of that to the drought, and a fraction of that to the conflict over water.
“In short, rising population and expanding industry and agriculture were greater causes of Syrian conflict than climate change—not to mention centuries-old religio-political conflicts, which dwarf them as causes of Syria’s civil war, the rise of ISIS, and the refugee crisis. And that was but one among many reasons for Brexit.”[22](javascript:void(0))
June 2015
“The idea of human-caused climate change is “un-biblical. The pope should back off. The Catholic church is correct on the ethical principles but has been misled on the science.”[23](javascript:void(0))
“Sad to say, despite Pope Francis’s best intentions, the policies he recommends to mitigate global warming would make it far more difficult to overcome poverty. And, ironically, by prolonging and even spreading poverty, those policies would put more of the natural environment at risk.”[24](javascript:void(0))
Calvin Beisner describes himself as an authority on climate change after having “read some 50 books […] on the science of climate change”:[25](javascript:void(0))
June 2014
“Environmentalism, as a movement, is an alternative world view and a substitute for Christianity. My principal concern about environmentalism is a religious, logical, ethical concern. My secondary concern is that its science and economics are often flawed in ways that would point us towards policies that are especially destructive and harmful to the world’s poor and, secondarily, everyone else.”[26](javascript:void(0))
November 2012
0:56-1:27 “God has said that all of the various cycles on which life depends are going to be sustained by his providential care from now until God ends heaven and Earth themselves in the last judgment. Now that too, I think, is contrary to fears that man-made climate change could bring an end to the various different climate cycles on which we depend and on which other forms of life depend for our thriving.”[27](javascript:void(0))
March 25, 2009
In his testimony before the Subcommittee on Energy and Environment of the Committee on Energy and Commerce, Beisner declared:
“I am convinced that policies meant to reduce alleged carbon dioxide-induced global warming will be destructive.”[28](javascript:void(0)) [29](javascript:void(0))
Key Deeds
September 24, 2020
Beisner appeared in Marc Morano’s 2020 film Climate Hustle 2: Rise of the Climate Monarchy, produced by the Committee for a Constructive Tomorrow (CFACT). During a discussion about how environmentalism could be used as a pretext to usher in an authoritarian political agenda, Morano asked Beisner: [30](javascript:void(0))
“But how can they [elite politicians] possibly get all the countries to willingly agree to give up their sovereignty?”
Beisner responded:
“If you can identify a threat that is global and then say we can only respond adequately to that threat with regulations that go across national borders. Now you have a rationale for global government.”
September 25, 2019
Beisner was a speaker at the 59th Annual Meeting of the Southern States Energy Board (SSEB). Former EPA administrator Scott Pruitt was among the event speakers. Beisner’s speech was titled “Economic and Social Benefits of Fossil Fuel Use.” Listen to the full audio, obtained by DeSmog, below:[31](javascript:void(0))
He summarized:
“I have a very simple point for you today: that because human material wellbeing depends heavily on access to abundant, affordable, reliable energy. Because fossil fuels are in the foreseeable future and will continue to be with nuclear and hydro, the world’s best source of such energy, and because of the benefits of added CO2 in the atmosphere to plant growth and consequently to the food supply for all animal and human life are enormous. The demand to reduce our use of fossil fuels, to reduce our CO2 emissions, to reduce man-made global warming, amounts to a demand to reduce human wellbeing and trap billions of people in poverty for generations to come,” Beiser said during his presentation.
He told the audience, made up of representatives from many in the energy industry, that they should embrace CO2 emissions and celebrate it:
“CO2 is the elixir of life. The world needs more of it not less. And fossil fuel companies should stop apologizing for it and embracing trends of emissions reductions. It never ceases to amaze me that fossil fuel companies, and industries that use fossil fuels, boast of reducing CO2 emissions. That just means pleading guilty and then begging for delayed execution.”[32](javascript:void(0))
You should be boasting all the benefits […] that the world gets not just from all that energy that you produce but also from a mere byproduct your activities, a byproduct you give to all the world without charging them a penny.”[33](javascript:void(0))
In his conclusion, Beisner portrays any movement away from fossil fuels as a campaign of “anti-humanism”:[34](javascript:void(0))
“The campaign to fight global warming by reducing fossil fuel use is […] a campaign to retain the primitive energy system and its accompanying low incomes and high rates of disease and premature death. It is in fact a campaign of anti-humanism.”
He also advertises the services of the Cornwall Alliance to provide “expert witnesses” to influence legislation: v
“The Cornwall Alliance can provide expert witnesses for legislative committees considering various legislation related to energy and climate […] we have some of the world’s top climate scientists, some of the world’s top energy economists and the like, among our network […] I would certainly welcome financial support for our efforts.”
Inside Climate News reported on the event, noting that the event had been sponsored by oil, gas, and coal companies such as American Electric Power, Duke Energy, Marathon and Phillips 66, as well as Koch Industries.[35](javascript:void(0))
Republican Governor Matt Bevin of Kentucky hosted the meeting. According to InsideClimateNews, He and other speakers at the conference “tried to cast doubt on mainstream climate science” and aimed to “get their fossil fuel message into the schools to influence children.”[36](javascript:void(0))
February 4, 2018
In January 2018, more than 200 scientists endorsed an open letter calling on the American Museum of Natural History (AMNH) to remove climate change denier Rebekah Mercer from its board and to “end ties to anti-science propagandists and funders of climate science misinformation.” The New York Times reported that those among the AMNH letter calling for Mercer to step down were Michael E. Mann, director of the Earth System Science Center at Pennsylvania State University, and Katharine Hayhoe, director of the Climate Science Center at Texas Tech University.[37](javascript:void(0))
Beisner was among a group of climate change deniers who responded with their own open letter, calling for the AMNH “not to cave in to this pressure.” The letter was signed by numerous individuals with ties to groups funded by the Mercer Family Foundation such as Will Happer of the CO2 CoalitionRichard Lindzen, a fellow at the Cato InstituteCraig Idso, the chairman of the Center for the Study of Carbon Dioxide and Global Change. There are a number of signatories affiliated with the Heartland Institute, which has received over $5.78 million from the Mercer Family Foundation since 2008.[38](javascript:void(0))
The letter reads:[39](javascript:void(0))
“The Earth has supported abundant life many times in the geological past when there were much higher levels of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. It is quite likely that future generations will benefit from the enrichment of Earth’s atmosphere with more carbon dioxide.
“Make no mistake, the agitators are not defending science from quackery — quite the contrary!”
May 17, 2017
The Cornwall Alliance is set to release a new documentary titled “Convicted: How Climate Alarmism Harms the World’s Poor” (working title) as the sequel to “Where the Grass is Greener: Biblical Stewardship vs. Climate Alarmism.”[40](javascript:void(0))
According to event description, the film would “delves into the deadly impacts of climate alarmism on people in developing countries, and what Biblical Stewardship requires of us: ‘To seek justice, love mercy, and walk humbly with our God.’”[41](javascript:void(0))
The event would be co-hosted with the Heritage Foundation, featuring E. Calvin Beisner and Becky Norton Dunlop.[42](javascript:void(0))
The Convicted trailer is available on Vimeo, from CDR Communications. Those featured in film include Tom Harris, Tim Ball, S. Fred Singer, Leighton Steward, Patrick J. Michaels, David Legates, among others.[43](javascript:void(0))
May 1–12, 2017
Calvin Beisner was hosted by the group Reformed Perspective (RP) for a speaking tour in Canada titled “The Grass is Greener: Biblical Stewardship in an Age of Climate Alarmism.” The event description on the RP website reads as follows:[44](javascript:void(0))
“If CO2 reductions, intended to fight future global warming, end up increasing heating costs now, should Christians be for or against them? And if these same CO2 reductions increase food costs, how will that impact the world’s poorest? Why don’t we hear environmentalists talking about the negative impact of their climate change plans? Is that because there aren’t any? And how does biblical stewardship differ from environmentalism in the way each views Man? Does having a Reformed perspective on the environment really matter? You bet it does!”[45](javascript:void(0))
Reformed Perspective describes itself as a “A Canadian-based monthly Christian magazine and website that looks at society and culture from a Calvinist viewpoint.” A recent issue of the RP magazine includes articles voicing concern over the inclusion of same-sex couples in the children’s magazine Highlights, and another article on what to do when a family member says they are gay. “The powerful, aggressive, LGBTQ lobby has been very successful in its efforts to normalize the homosexual lifestyle in our society,” the article reads, which also mentions a DVD resource on the topic.
DeSmog attended one of the events in Alberta and captured some key moments from Beisner’s presentation. Beisner said the presentation was a condensed version of a lecture he had given at Penn State one year prior titled “Climate science, energy policy, poverty, and Christian faith: How do they connect?[46](javascript:void(0)) [47](javascript:void(0))
A central argument to Beisner’s presentation is that CO2 reductions would harm the poor. “The kinds of policies that are being recommended for us to respond to man-made global warming are policies, every one of them, that would bring enormous harm to the world’s poorest,” Beisner said.[48](javascript:void(0))
Citing research by Craig Idso, Beisner claims that “if you project where CO2 is headed, from 2012 to 2050, You can project an added $9.3 trillion worth of crop yield around the world. […] This is a very, very good thing for the world’s poor.” He implies that, conversely, environmentalists may want people to die off in order to reduce global population:[49](javascript:void(0))
“Sometimes I wonder whether some of the environmentalists want us to be able to feed a growing human population. The top leaders of the world’s largest environmental NGOs […] generally agree that the maximum sustainable human population is about half a billion people. Which means we have to get rid of about 95% of us. So, maybe they’re not real excited about being able to feed more people. But I am. Because I value people. Because people are made in God’s image.
They are crowned with glory and honor and given dominion over everything that moves on the face of the Earth. We are the pinnacle of creation. We are not, as environmentalists tend to describe us, basically just consumers and polluters using up the Earth’s resources. The Earth’s resources? How does the Earth own anything? And polluting the planet while we’re at it. That’s not what we are made to be. We are made to be producers and stewards of God’s Earth.”[50](javascript:void(0))
Beisner also addressed his views on climate change, asserting that it is natural and cyclical, while remaining open to those who might believe in “a Earth that is perhaps eight or ten thousand years old”:
“Do I believe that global warming is real? Absolutely. Sure. And I also believe that global cooling is real. Warming and cooling have gone back and forth cyclically throughout Earth’s history. Whether you’re somebody who believes in an Earth that’s billions of years old, or somebody who believes in an Earth that is perhaps eight or ten thousand years old, either way, Earth’s history shows us that warming and cooling have gone back and forth cyclically all through Earth’s history.
[…] So, do I believe global warming is real? Yes. So, I’m not a climate change denier. I’m certainly not a climate denier.”
He added that any warming that does occur would be ““So little we cannot detect it. And if it’s that little, then it’s not going to have all kinds of disastrous effects.”[51](javascript:void(0))
According to Beisner, “the whole concept of global average temperature is almost meaningless.” He quotes his “friend Doctor Richard Lindzen” who said that “’the appropriate response to this,’ using very technical scientific language, is ‘so what?’”[52](javascript:void(0))
Referring to the research process conducted by Roy Spencer, Beisner said it just doesn’t make sense that “God designed a climate system that, with a tiny, tiny change in global average surface temperature would go into collapse”:[53](javascript:void(0))
“God did promise Himself, Genesis 822, after the flood, that as long as heaven and Earth endured, day and night, summer and winter, cold and heat, seed time to harvest would not cease. So we have God’s own promise of sustaining the cycle on which life depends,” Beisner said.[54](javascript:void(0))
Beisner, who earlier in his talk described climate science as “the most complex natural system we’ve ever studied with the exception of the human brain and DNA,” describes CO2 and temperature as “pretty basic scientific reasoning”:[55](javascript:void(0))
“On long time periods, CO2 follows temperatures by about 200 to 800 years. But on fairly short time periods of a century or less, CO2 changes about nine to twelve-and-a-half months after temperature changes. Which means, to speak in technical scientific terms again, that the alarmists have put the cart before the horse. This is not rocket science. It’s not that difficult to understand these things. This is pretty basic scientific reasoning.“[56](javascript:void(0))
He describes renewable energy as “immoral,” and urges the audience to tell their local officials to stay out of the Paris Climate Agreement:[57](javascript:void(0))
“In Britain, excess winter death rates have risen by more than 300% since the early 2000s because of the policies they’re pushing for more wind and solar and less use of coal and natural gas to generate electricity. This I think is immoral. The 2nd great commandment says love thy neighbor as thyself. […][58](javascript:void(0))
“I want you to communicate to your elected representatives […] telling them, I don’t want us participating in the Paris Climate Agreement or any other mandated reduction of CO2 emissions and fossil fuel use because I want to protect the poor from harm.”[59](javascript:void(0))
May 8, 2017
Beisner, representing the Cornwall Alliance, is a signatory to an open letter to President Donald J. Trump urging him “to withdraw fully from the Paris Climate Treaty and to stop all taxpayer funding of UN global warming programs.”[60](javascript:void(0))
DeSmog reported that the 40 groups represented in the letter, including the Competitive Enterprise Institute (CEI), The Heartland Institute, and the Heritage Foundation, have received a combined total of millions of dollars from the Koch Brothers, ExxonMobil, and other industry groups.[61](javascript:void(0))
Analysis also showed that the groups accepted about $80 million through Donors Capital Fund and Donors Trust, two groups that have been confirmed is a key financial source for key U.S-based climate change denial groups.[62](javascript:void(0))
